Other Publications

Education Columns

Teaching An Old Dog New Tricks: Experiences of a Junior Faculty Teaching an Experienced Faculty Learner

By James E. Hougas, III, MD, FAAFP

 

The creation of a new colonoscopy program at the family medicine residency brought many challenges. Only the newest teaching faculty (TF) had the privileges and experience to perform the procedure. The first plan was to recredential another faculty member who had previously performed colonoscopy but had not done so in years. Teaching an experienced faculty learner (EFL) is a unique situation. The EFL had almost quadruple the years of clinical experience and twice the years of teaching experience compared to the TF.

Skill Assessment

Many procedures can be taught in a specific order with an expected progression. In colonoscopy, each subskill builds on the prior skill, and the learner takes on more and more of the procedure.

Differences with EFL:

The EFL may experience mastery of skills earlier than expected. EFL confidence and nonlinear skill acquisition may mask areas where skill refinement is needed because of inaccurate assumptions by the TF.

Approach to the EFL:

An initial assessment was conducted by the TF with supervised colonoscopy simulation. The TF and EFL coconstructed an accelerated training plan based on the EFL’s self-reflection. The TF elicited EFL’s opinions on the training, progress, and next direction frequently. The TF reevaluated procedural competencies regularly.

Style Differences

Learners regularly adopt practice styles similar to their TF. The shared style allows the TF to predict the learner’s actions and efficiently correct skills. This happens through a shared vision of each skill.

Differences with EFL:

The EFL previously trained with different TF and has a preexisting style.

Approach to the EFL:

The TF has a responsibility to evaluate the EFL’s current approach and offer alternatives while maintaining safety. After the EFL demonstrated the ability to recognize their limits, the TF gave them ample opportunity to struggle and troubleshoot a skill. The TF would offer their approach and allow the EFL to independently assess the merits of that style.

Hierarchy/Readiness to Assume the Role of the Learner

The majority of learners in graduate medical education have less clinical and procedural experience than their TF. Based on their level of training, the learner has a concept of decisions they are allowed to make independently and which require consultation with the TF.

Differences with EFL:

The EFL has been practicing independently longer than the TF and is distant from residency. The TF and EFL are also peers in a larger university-based, full-spectrum practice.

Approach to the EFL:

The TF leveraged the EFL’s experience with the procedure to allow the EFL the first chance to determine the support they needed. The EFL’s insights allowed the TF to evaluate competency and offer guidance. Because of the EFL’s capability, the TF would ask more questions like “How can I help you?” and “Where were you getting hung up?” Guidance was delivered with “What I would do here…”, “You could consider…”, or “How about you try… .” In debriefs, the EFL could better articulate what training they needed next. Conflict was generally avoided because of the previous cocreation of the training plan.

Final Thoughts

The process of teaching an EFL is a unique one. Because of the EFL’s own teaching abilities and experience, the TF was able to have direct and well-articulated feedback on the TF’s teaching style. The TF frequently requested this feedback, which also helped maintain the peer relationship.

 

Ask a Question
AI Chatbot Tips

Tips for Using STFM's AI Assistant

STFM's AI Assistant is designed to help you find information and answers about Family Medicine education. While it's a powerful tool, getting the best results depends on how you phrase your questions. Here's how to make the most of your interactions:

1. Avoid Ambiguous Language

Be Clear and Specific: Use precise terms and avoid vague words like "it" or "that" without clear references.

Example:
Instead of: "Can you help me with that?"
Try: "Can you help me update our Family Medicine clerkship curriculum?"
Why this is important: Ambiguous language can confuse the AI, leading to irrelevant or unclear responses. Clear references help the chatbot understand exactly what you're asking.

2. Use Specific Terms

Identify the Subject Clearly: Clearly state the subject or area you need information about.

Example:
Instead of: "What resources does STFM provide?"
Try: "I'm a new program coordinator for a Family Medicine clerkship. What STFM resources are available to help me design or update clerkship curricula?"
Why this is better: Providing details about your role ("program coordinator") and your goal ("design or update clerkship curricula") gives the chatbot enough context to offer more targeted information.

3. Don't Assume the AI Knows Everything

Provide Necessary Details:The STFM AI Assistant has been trained on STFM's business and resources. The AI can only use the information you provide or that it has been trained on.

Example:
Instead of: "How can I improve my program?"
Try: "As a program coordinator for a Family Medicine clerkship, what resources does STFM provide to help me improve student engagement and learning outcomes?"
Why this is important: Including relevant details helps the AI understand your specific situation, leading to more accurate and useful responses.

4. Reset if You Change Topics

Clear Chat History When Switching Topics:

If you move to a completely new topic and the chatbot doesn't recognize the change, click the Clear Chat History button and restate your question.
Note: Clearing your chat history removes all previous context from the chatbot's memory.
Why this is important: Resetting ensures the AI does not carry over irrelevant information, which could lead to confusion or inaccurate answers.

5. Provide Enough Context

Include Background Information: The more context you provide, the better the chatbot can understand and respond to your question.

Example:
Instead of: "What are the best practices?"
Try: "In the context of Family Medicine education, what are the best practices for integrating clinical simulations into the curriculum?"
Why this is important: Specific goals, constraints, or preferences allow the AI to tailor its responses to your unique needs.

6. Ask One Question at a Time

Break Down Complex Queries: If you have multiple questions, ask them separately.

Example:
Instead of: "What are the requirements for faculty development, how do I register for conferences, and what grants are available?"
Try: Start with "What are the faculty development requirements for Family Medicine educators?" Then follow up with your other questions after receiving the response.
Why this is important: This approach ensures each question gets full attention and a complete answer.

Examples of Good vs. Bad Prompts

Bad Prompt

"What type of membership is best for me?"

Why it's bad: The AI Chat Assistant has no information about your background or needs.

Good Prompt

"I'm the chair of the Department of Family Medicine at a major university, and I plan to retire next year. I'd like to stay involved with Family Medicine education. What type of membership is best for me?"

Why it's good: The AI Chat Assistant knows your role, your future plans, and your interest in staying involved, enabling it to provide more relevant advice.

Double Check Important Information

While the AI Chat Assistant is a helpful tool, it can still produce inaccurate or incomplete responses. Always verify critical information with reliable sources or colleagues before taking action.

Technical Limitations

The Chat Assistant:

  • Cannot access external websites or open links
  • Cannot process or view images
  • Cannot make changes to STFM systems or process transactions
  • Cannot access real-time information (like your STFM Member Profile information)

STFM AI Assistant
Disclaimer: The STFM Assistant can make mistakes. Check important information.