Other Publications

Education Columns

Lessons From a Symposium on Incorporating Entrustable Professional Activities Into Medical School Curricula

by Tomoko Sairenji, MD, MS, Sarah Stumbar, MD, MPH; Kirby Clark, MD; Kristen Hood Watson, MD; Danielle Bienz, MEd; Stephen Scott, MD, MPH; Javad Keyhani, MD; Suzanne Minor, MD; Franklyn Babb, MD; Magdalena Pasarica, MD, PhD; Christine Savi, PhD

The Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC)’s Core Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) for Entering  Residency encompass 13 activities that medical students should perform upon entering residency. Medical schools must re-evaluate teaching and assessment methods to prepare students in the competency domain. At the 2019 Society of Teachers of Family Medicine Conference on Medical Student Education, seven schools discussed institutional EPA implementation at their institutions in the presentation "Symposium on Incorporating EPAs into Medical School Curricula." We offer a summary of the SWOT analysis (Strengths-Weaknesses-Opportunities-Threats) completed by participants regarding EPA curricular incorporation. 

Strengths:
Interest/buy-in. It is critical to have faculty and leadership support to champion EPAs; working together across clerkships is necessary for broader implementation. Community preceptor interest and motivation to carry out the requirements of the curriculum helps to facilitate successful implementation. 
Assessment. Medical institutions value EPA assessments because they are objective, longitudinal, formative, and summative. EPAs align with schools’ educational program objectives (EPOs) and provide measurable criteria for assessing competence across a developmental continuum. Because they are modeled after the GME residency milestones, EPAs facilitate a seamless transition from undergraduate medical education to graduate medical education.
New schools/curriculums. New schools have opportunities to allow just-in-time integration, where alignment and integration can be spiraled throughout the curriculum at the onset.
Required status. There are indications that AAMC will require schools to integrate EPAs.
Central location. Offering one central location for the education of medical learners can facilitate easier integration.

Weaknesses:
Faculty development. Teaching preceptors how to use the EPAs across multiple clerkship sites takes time and can be a challenge as few resources exist in this area. 
Getting buy-in from key stakeholders. EPA assessment and gathering multiple data-points can be difficult. Student disengagement with EPA assessment is often associated with its impact on residency applications. Incorporating EPAs requires additional time and effort from clerkship directors, already burdened by administrative tasks. Gaining buy-in from preceptors and students to engage in this process is key.
Working with other clerkships and tracking performance over time. Financial and technological resources are necessary to incorporate and assess EPAs across settings. Standard technologies that institutions can utilize is lacking.

Opportunities: 
Transition. Opportunities exists during times of transition. Change in leadership may impact change for the clerkship director, department chair, or dean. Curriculum changes may include transitioning to student portfolios or changing from a block structure to a longitudinal integrated clerkship.  
Liaison Committee on Medical Education (LCME). Leveraging upcoming LCME visits to implement EPA assessments in curriculum can be helpful. 
Feedback. EPAs can facilitate feedback for learners and educators. Clerkship directors can provide faculty development to preceptors about how to give formative feedback to learners. A common language for delivering feedback can be gained by using the assessment anchors. 
Growing as educators. This is an opportunity for preceptors to grow as teachers, connect with the learning community, and possibly earn CME credit.  

Threats:
Time and complexity. Teaching EPA concepts to busy students and community preceptors across a region is difficult. Creating efficient means to do this via text, audio, video, and live or virtual meeting takes time and effort. 
Preceptor buy-in/burn out. Preceptors must find time to utilize the EPA tool, which may prevent preceptors from taking medical students. Creating efficient methods to use EPAs, providing incentives, and offering electronic dashboards to track student improvement may help with engagement.
Institutional buy-in. Institutions may be excited to have EPAs, but must commit to providing resources, time and money to the people involved.
Student buy-in. Asking students to be the front line of EPAs is a hard sell. Awarding students credit for participation may mitigate this risk. 
Lack of objective evidence: EPAs have literature-based origins, however there is little evidence that they create better-prepared residents. Tracking Step 2-CS scores and intern milestone ratings may offer correlation with performance.

Conclusion:
The SWOT activity facilitated reflection about EPA implementation from participating institutions. Our collective experiences provided rich fodder for consideration which we hope will be useful to others as they implement the EPAs.

 

Ask a Question
AI Chatbot Tips

Tips for Using STFM's AI Assistant

STFM's AI Assistant is designed to help you find information and answers about Family Medicine education. While it's a powerful tool, getting the best results depends on how you phrase your questions. Here's how to make the most of your interactions:

1. Avoid Ambiguous Language

Be Clear and Specific: Use precise terms and avoid vague words like "it" or "that" without clear references.

Example:
Instead of: "Can you help me with that?"
Try: "Can you help me update our Family Medicine clerkship curriculum?"
Why this is important: Ambiguous language can confuse the AI, leading to irrelevant or unclear responses. Clear references help the chatbot understand exactly what you're asking.

2. Use Specific Terms

Identify the Subject Clearly: Clearly state the subject or area you need information about.

Example:
Instead of: "What resources does STFM provide?"
Try: "I'm a new program coordinator for a Family Medicine clerkship. What STFM resources are available to help me design or update clerkship curricula?"
Why this is better: Providing details about your role ("program coordinator") and your goal ("design or update clerkship curricula") gives the chatbot enough context to offer more targeted information.

3. Don't Assume the AI Knows Everything

Provide Necessary Details:The STFM AI Assistant has been trained on STFM's business and resources. The AI can only use the information you provide or that it has been trained on.

Example:
Instead of: "How can I improve my program?"
Try: "As a program coordinator for a Family Medicine clerkship, what resources does STFM provide to help me improve student engagement and learning outcomes?"
Why this is important: Including relevant details helps the AI understand your specific situation, leading to more accurate and useful responses.

4. Reset if You Change Topics

Clear Chat History When Switching Topics:

If you move to a completely new topic and the chatbot doesn't recognize the change, click the Clear Chat History button and restate your question.
Note: Clearing your chat history removes all previous context from the chatbot's memory.
Why this is important: Resetting ensures the AI does not carry over irrelevant information, which could lead to confusion or inaccurate answers.

5. Provide Enough Context

Include Background Information: The more context you provide, the better the chatbot can understand and respond to your question.

Example:
Instead of: "What are the best practices?"
Try: "In the context of Family Medicine education, what are the best practices for integrating clinical simulations into the curriculum?"
Why this is important: Specific goals, constraints, or preferences allow the AI to tailor its responses to your unique needs.

6. Ask One Question at a Time

Break Down Complex Queries: If you have multiple questions, ask them separately.

Example:
Instead of: "What are the requirements for faculty development, how do I register for conferences, and what grants are available?"
Try: Start with "What are the faculty development requirements for Family Medicine educators?" Then follow up with your other questions after receiving the response.
Why this is important: This approach ensures each question gets full attention and a complete answer.

Examples of Good vs. Bad Prompts

Bad Prompt

"What type of membership is best for me?"

Why it's bad: The AI Chat Assistant has no information about your background or needs.

Good Prompt

"I'm the chair of the Department of Family Medicine at a major university, and I plan to retire next year. I'd like to stay involved with Family Medicine education. What type of membership is best for me?"

Why it's good: The AI Chat Assistant knows your role, your future plans, and your interest in staying involved, enabling it to provide more relevant advice.

Double Check Important Information

While the AI Chat Assistant is a helpful tool, it can still produce inaccurate or incomplete responses. Always verify critical information with reliable sources or colleagues before taking action.

Technical Limitations

The Chat Assistant:

  • Cannot access external websites or open links
  • Cannot process or view images
  • Cannot make changes to STFM systems or process transactions
  • Cannot access real-time information (like your STFM Member Profile information)

STFM AI Assistant
Disclaimer: The STFM Assistant can make mistakes. Check important information.