Experiential Learning to Access Awe and Wonder Improves the Mood of Participating Residents

By Christopher Haymaker, PhD; Austin Brubaker, MA; Western Michigan University Homer Stryker M.D. School of Medicine, Kalamazoo, MI; Melanie Olivas Longhurst, PhD, Med; Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center El Paso, El Paso, TX; Lynn Lamb, PsyD; Kaiser Permanente Santa Rosa Medical Center, Santa Rosa, CA

INTRODUCTION

Experiential learning is a cornerstone of effective medical education, particularly in didactic settings in which learners benefit from opportunities for reflection. Meaningful experiences can challenge existing knowledge structures, promote deeper learning, and encourage self-reflection. Such experiences may also support professional identity formation by helping trainees connect personal values with their emerging roles as physicians.

Awe and wonder may be useful within this framework. Awe is the feeling associated with encountering something perceived as vast or transcendent, whereas wonder is a reflective state characterized by openness and curiosity. These experiences often occur together during transformative learning experiences.1-3 Awe and wonder have been associated with connectedness, humility, and reduced distress.1 Among health care professionals, daily experiences of awe have also been associated with improved well-being and reduced stress.3

Awe and wonder may help medical learners connect with personal values and sustain empathy throughout their careers.4,5 These emotions can arise during transformative experiences and may promote self-reflection.1,2,6 We sought to assess changes in affect among family medicine residents participating in a didactic session designed to facilitate experiences of awe and wonder.

METHODS

We recruited family medicine residents from 3 residency programs: Western Michigan University Homer Stryker MD School of Medicine, Kaiser Permanente Santa Rosa Family Medicine Residency Program in California, and Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center El Paso Family Medicine Residency Program. The institutional review boards at each institution determined that the study was exempt from review. Participants constituted a convenience sample of residents present during a scheduled didactic session. All 46 residents participated in the session; 42 consented to the use of their data for scholarly purposes.

The authors facilitated 50-minute didactic sessions7 designed to promote experiences of awe and wonder. Facilitators first defined the concepts and discussed their potential associations with reduced burnout and improved well-being (10-15 minutes). Participants then completed a 16-minute photo scavenger hunt during which they captured images, without human identifiers, that evoked awe. On returning, participants formed groups of 3 or 4 to discuss their images and reflect on the experience (5 minutes). Participants then provided a 1-sentence written summary of what had inspired them. Facilitators concluded with a structured debriefing focused on participants' reactions and insights (10 minutes).

The Positive and Negative Affect Schedule (PANAS) is a reliable and valid 20-item measure of positive affect (Table 1) and negative affect (Table 2), with items rated on a Likert-type scale.8 We selected the PANAS because it has been extensively studied and allowed us to assess a range of emotional responses to the didactic session. Participants completed the PANAS immediately before and after the session. Open-ended survey items elicited qualitative responses to the prompts, "This inspired awe in me because..." and "Please share your comments about the value of this activity."

Table 1. Positive Affect Items Analysis of Change

 

Item

Average Change

from pre to post

Wilcoxon signed rank p-value for significant change between pre and post test values.

Interested

+0.43

.0181*

Excited

+0.78

.0001*

Strong

+0.20

.9523

Enthusiastic

+0.53

.0015*

Proud

+0.19

.6133

Alert

+0.24

.2238

Inspired

+.38

.1757

Determined

-0.19

.1072

Attentive

+0.16

.9896

Active

+0.47

.0073*

OVERALL PA

+3.23

.0065*

 

* p<.05

Table 2. Negative Affect Items Analysis of Change

 

Item

Average Change

from pre to post

Wilcoxon signed rank p-value for significant change between pre and post test values.

Distressed

-0.72

.0002*

Upset

-0.40

.0918

Guilty

-0.34

.0287*

Scared

-0.42

.0469

Hostile

-0.23

.2500

Irritable

-0.56

.0015*

Ashamed

-0.20

.1719

Nervous

-0.81

<.0001*

Jittery

-0.33

.0327

Afraid

-0.25

.6152

OVERALL NA

-4.37

.0001*

 

* p<.05

RESULTS

Analysis revealed overall increases in positive affect (Table 1) and decreases in negative affect (Table 2). Statistically significant increases were observed for the PANAS items interested, excited, enthusiastic, and active. Statistically significant decreases were observed for distressed, guilty, irritable, nervous, and jittery.

Common themes in participants' comments included gratitude, calm, connection, and hopefulness. Representative responses included, "I feel peaceful," "I was given time to reflect," and "There is hope." One participant wrote that the activity "makes me feel small in the 'wow, this world is so cool' kind of way." Another appreciated "time with other residents I don't get the opportunity to speak with." A participant who described having been in "robot mode with work" during the previous 2 weeks characterized the activity as relaxing and reassuring and reported that it "woke up a bit of happiness" that they had not allowed themselves to feel recently.

DISCUSSION

Participation in a didactic session focused on awe and wonder was associated with immediate improvements in affect among family medicine residents, including decreases in several negative affect measures and increases in several positive affect measures. Participants' qualitative responses also reflected feelings of gratitude, calm, hopefulness, and connection with themselves and others.

Positive affect has been associated with cognitive processing, creativity, learning, and interpersonal connection.9 For residents working in demanding clinical environments, structured opportunities to experience positive emotions and reconnect with personal values may provide meaningful opportunities for reflection and connection. The session described here offers a brief, experiential approach that can be incorporated into residency didactic programming.

This study had several limitations. The sample included 42 residents from 3 family medicine residency programs and was based on convenience sampling. In addition, the study did not include a control or comparison group. Changes in affect therefore cannot be attributed specifically to awe and wonder and may have been influenced by other aspects of the session, including time away from usual responsibilities, outdoor activity, or social interaction with peers. The study also assessed affect only immediately before and after the intervention and did not evaluate whether changes persisted over time.

Future studies could examine the durability of changes in affect, compare awe- and wonder-based interventions with other experiential activities, and evaluate whether repeated sessions are associated with longer-term changes in resident well-being.

REFERENCES

  1. Shiota MN. Awe, wonder, and the human mind. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 2021;1501(1):85-89. doi:10.1111/nyas.14588
  2. Silva Luna D, Bering J. Varieties of awe in science communication: reflexive thematic analysis of practitioners' experiences and uses of this emotion. Sci Commun. 2022;44:107554702210981. doi:10.1177/10755470221098100
  3. Monroy M, Uğurlu Ö, Zerwas F, et al. The influences of daily experiences of awe on stress, somatic health, and well-being: a longitudinal study during COVID-19. Sci Rep. 2023;13(1):9336. doi:10.1038/s41598-023-35200-w
  4. Geller G, Shin S, Goldberg H, Merritt MW. Capacity for wonder among medical students: assessment and educational implications. Med Teach. 2023;45(1):68-72. doi:10.1080/0142159X.2022.2099260
  5. Weger U, Wagemann J. Towards a conceptual clarification of awe and wonder: a first-person phenomenological enquiry. Curr Psychol. 2021;40(3):1386-1401. doi:10.1007/s12144-018-0057-7
  6. Taylor DCM, Hamdy H. Adult learning theories: implications for learning and teaching in medical education: AMEE Guide No. 83. Med Teach. 2013;35(11). doi:10.3109/0142159X.2013.828153
  7. Haymaker C, Longhurst M, Lamb L. Awe and wonder: an experiential learning activity for medical learners and faculty. Professional Well-Being Collaborative Library, STFM Connect. Published October 7, 2025. Accessed October 7, 2025. https://connect.stfm.org/viewdocument/awe-and-wonder-an-experiential-lea?CommunityKey=e3fd7427-e8fe-4926-ab5b-722754775705
  8. Watson D, Clark LA, Tellegen A. Development and validation of brief measures of positive and negative affect: the PANAS scales. J Pers Soc Psychol. 1988;54(6):1063-1070. doi:10.1037/0022-3514.54.6.1063
  9. Lyubomirsky S, King L, Diener E. The benefits of frequent positive affect: does happiness lead to success? Psychol Bull. 2005;131(6):803-855.

Want to Read More STFM Education Columns or Learn How to Submit One?

Ask a Question
AI Chatbot Tips

Tips for Using STFM's AI Assistant

STFM's AI Assistant is designed to help you find information and answers about Family Medicine education. While it's a powerful tool, getting the best results depends on how you phrase your questions. Here's how to make the most of your interactions:

1. Avoid Ambiguous Language

Be Clear and Specific: Use precise terms and avoid vague words like "it" or "that" without clear references.

Example:

Instead of: "Can you help me with that?"
Try: "Can you help me update our Family Medicine clerkship curriculum?"
Why this is important: Ambiguous language can confuse the AI, leading to irrelevant or unclear responses. Clear references help the chatbot understand exactly what you're asking.

2. Use Specific Terms

Identify the Subject Clearly: Clearly state the subject or area you need information about.

Example:

Instead of: "What resources does STFM provide?"
Try: "I'm a new program coordinator for a Family Medicine clerkship. What STFM resources are available to help me design or update clerkship curricula?"
Why this is better: Providing details about your role ("program coordinator") and your goal ("design or update clerkship curricula") gives the chatbot enough context to offer more targeted information.

3. Don't Assume the AI Knows Everything

Provide Necessary Details:The STFM AI Assistant has been trained on STFM's business and resources. The AI can only use the information you provide or that it has been trained on.

Example:

Instead of: "How can I improve my program?"
Try: "As a program coordinator for a Family Medicine clerkship, what resources does STFM provide to help me improve student engagement and learning outcomes?"
Why this is important: Including relevant details helps the AI understand your specific situation, leading to more accurate and useful responses.

4. Reset if You Change Topics

Clear Chat History When Switching Topics:

If you move to a completely new topic and the chatbot doesn't recognize the change, click the Clear Chat History button and restate your question.
Note: Clearing your chat history removes all previous context from the chatbot's memory.
Why this is important: Resetting ensures the AI does not carry over irrelevant information, which could lead to confusion or inaccurate answers.

5. Provide Enough Context

Include Background Information: The more context you provide, the better the chatbot can understand and respond to your question.

Example:

Instead of: "What are the best practices?"
Try: "In the context of Family Medicine education, what are the best practices for integrating clinical simulations into the curriculum?"
Why this is important: Specific goals, constraints, or preferences allow the AI to tailor its responses to your unique needs.

6. Ask One Question at a Time

Break Down Complex Queries: If you have multiple questions, ask them separately.

Example:

Instead of: "What are the requirements for faculty development, how do I register for conferences, and what grants are available?"
Try: Start with "What are the faculty development requirements for Family Medicine educators?" Then follow up with your other questions after receiving the response.
Why this is important: This approach ensures each question gets full attention and a complete answer.

Examples of Good vs. Bad Prompts

Bad Prompt

"What type of membership is best for me?"

Why it's bad: The AI Chat Assistant has no information about your background or needs.

Good Prompt

"I'm the chair of the Department of Family Medicine at a major university, and I plan to retire next year. I'd like to stay involved with Family Medicine education. What type of membership is best for me?"

Why it's good: The AI Chat Assistant knows your role, your future plans, and your interest in staying involved, enabling it to provide more relevant advice.

Double Check Important Information

While the AI Chat Assistant is a helpful tool, it can still produce inaccurate or incomplete responses. Always verify critical information with reliable sources or colleagues before taking action.

Technical Limitations

The Chat Assistant:

  • Cannot access external websites or open links
  • Cannot process or view images
  • Cannot make changes to STFM systems or process transactions
  • Cannot access real-time information (like your STFM Member Profile information)

STFM AI Assistant
Disclaimer: The STFM Assistant can make mistakes. Check important information.